Overview and Direct Answer
Section 172 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) defines the substantive offence of personation at an election (commonly known as bogus voting or double voting), which is punishable under Section 174 BNS with imprisonment of either description up to one year, or fine, or both S1, s. 172; S1, s. 174. Replacing Section 171D of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC), Section 172 BNS criminalises three distinct forms of conduct at an election: (1) applying for a voting paper or voting in the name of any other person (whether living, dead, or fictitious), (2) applying at the same election for a voting paper in one's own name after having already voted once at that election, and (3) abetting, procuring, or attempting to procure such voting by any person S1, s. 172; S3, s. 171D. The enacted text of Section 172 BNS consolidates the Proviso (originally inserted into IPC Section 171D by the Election and Other Related Laws (Amendment) Act, 2003, Act 24 of 2003) that exempts a person duly authorised to vote as a proxy for an elector (such as a classified service voter) under any law in force S1, s. 172; S4, s. 172.
Statutory Text and Three Modes of Committing Personation
Section 172 BNS states:
"Whoever at an election applies for a voting paper on votes in the name of any other person, whether living or dead, or in a fictitious name, or who having voted once at such election applies at the same election for a voting paper in his own name, and whoever abets, procures or attempts to procure the voting by any person in any such way, commits the offence of personation at an election: Provided that nothing in this section shall apply to a person who has been authorised to vote as proxy for an elector under any law for the time being in force in so far as he votes as a proxy for such elector." S1, s. 172
(Note on Gazette Typography: Just as in many official prints of IPC Section 171D, the phrase "applies for a voting paper on votes" is a typographical rendering of "applies for a voting paper or votes", and in the Electronic Voting Machine (EVM) era, applying for a voter slip / signing or thumb-marking the Register of Voters in Form 17A and pressing the ballot unit button are treated as the functional and legal equivalents of applying for a voting paper and voting under Section 61A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 and Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961) S1, s. 172; S3, s. 171D.
Let us break down each of the three statutory limbs and the Proviso:
- Limb 1: False Identity Voting (
"in the name of any other person, whether living or dead, or in a fictitious name"):- The offence is complete as soon as the accused applies for a ballot/voting paper (or presents themselves before the Polling Officer to be issued access to the EVM ballot unit) in the name of:
- Another living person on the electoral roll;
- A deceased person whose name still appears on the electoral roll; or
- A fictitious name entered on the roll S1, s. 172.
- Stage of Completion: Because the statute covers anyone who
"applies for a voting paper", the offence of personation is complete the moment the impostor applies to the polling official in the false name, even if the polling agent immediately challenges their identity (under Rule 36 of the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961) and prevents them from actually casting a vote S1, s. 172!
- The offence is complete as soon as the accused applies for a ballot/voting paper (or presents themselves before the Polling Officer to be issued access to the EVM ballot unit) in the name of:
- Limb 2: Double Voting in One's Own Name (
"having voted once at such election applies at the same election for a voting paper in his own name"):- A person who is a genuine registered voter, and whose name was mistakenly printed at two different serial numbers or in two polling booths of the same constituency, commits personation under Section 172 BNS if, after having voted once at such election, they apply again at the same election in their own name S1, s. 172.
- Thus, in Indian criminal law,
"personation at elections"is a term of art that encompasses plural/repeat voting in one's own true name at the same election, not just impersonating someone else S1, s. 172!
- Limb 3: Abetting, Procuring, or Attempting to Procure Personation:
- Anyone who
"abets, procures or attempts to procure the voting by any person in any such way"is made a principal offender committing"personation at an election"under Section 172 BNS itself S1, s. 172. For instance, a polling booth agent or candidate's worker who supplies fake voter slips to bogus voters or falsely identifies an impostor before the Presiding Officer commits the principal offence under Section 172 BNS S1, s. 172.
- Anyone who
- The Proviso: Protection for Authorised Proxy Voters:
- Under Section 60(b) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 (inserted by Act 24 of 2003),
"classified service voters"(such as members of the Armed Forces or personnel governed by the Army Act, 1950 or BSF/CRPF posted away from home) may appoint a resident proxy to vote on their behalf at the polling station. - Because a proxy voter casts a vote in the name of the service voter (and may also cast a second vote in their own name as an ordinary elector of that constituency!), their conduct would literally fall within Limb 1 and Limb 2 of Section 172 BNS were it not for the Proviso, which immunises the proxy
"in so far as he votes as a proxy for such elector"S1, s. 172.
- Under Section 60(b) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 (inserted by Act 24 of 2003),
Required Mental Element (Mens Rea): Mistake of Fact vs. Corrupt Intent
Does Section 172 BNS create strict liability if an illiterate or elderly voter mistakenly believes that their name on the electoral roll is the entry belonging to another person of the same name (Ram Lal, son of Mohan Lal)?
- No. By virtue of Section 3(1) BNS, every offence definition in the Sanhita is subject to Chapter III (General Exceptions, Sections 14–44 BNS), including Section 17 BNS (act done by a person justified, or by mistake of fact in good faith believing himself justified, by law) S1, s. 3(1); S1, s. 17; S1, s. 172.
- Indian High Courts construing IPC Section 171D have consistently held that mens rea (knowledge that one is not the elector entered on the roll, or knowledge that one has already voted once) is an essential ingredient of personation at an election; a bona fide mistake induced by a polling clerk's error in reading out a similar father's name or house number does not constitute an offence under Section 172 BNS S1, s. 17; S1, s. 172.
Comparison with IPC Section 171D
| Aspect | IPC, 1860 (Section 171D) | BNS, 2023 (Section 172) | Legal & Procedural Comparison |
|---|---|---|---|
| Substantive Wording | Section 171D + Proviso (inserted by Act 24 of 2003) S3, s. 171D | Section 172 + Proviso S1, s. 172 | Substantively identical S1, s. 172; S5. |
| Punishment Provision | Punished under IPC Section 171F (up to 1 year, or fine, or both) S3, s. 171F | Punished under BNS Section 174 (up to 1 year, or fine, or both) S1, s. 174 | Substantive sentence unchanged S1, s. 174. |
| Procedural Classification Change (CrPC vs. BNSS) | Under CrPC 1973 First Schedule, personation at an election (IPC 171F Part II) was Cognizable (while undue influence was Non-cognizable). | Under BNSS 2023 First Schedule, Section 174 BNS has a single unified entry: Non-cognizable, Bailable, Triable by Magistrate of the first class S4, s. 174. | Major procedural change in BNSS: Personation at an election (punished under Section 174 BNS) is now classified as Non-cognizable in the BNSS First Schedule S4, s. 174. |
Practical Examples and Counterexamples
- Editorial Hypothetical 1 (Apprehended at Polling Booth Before Pressing EVM Button: Offence Complete):
- Assumed Facts: During a Municipal election, X enters Polling Booth No. 42 carrying the Voter ID card of his deceased uncle U and applies to the First Polling Officer for a voter slip in U's name. A rival candidate's polling agent recognises X, raises a challenge by depositing ₹2, and proves that U died two years ago. X is stopped before he can reach the EVM compartment.
- Analysis: X has already committed the completed offence of personation at an election under Section 172 BNS (punishable under Section 174 BNS), because Section 172 BNS is triggered as soon as a person
"applies for a voting paper"in the name of another living or dead person S1, s. 172; S1, s. 174.
- Editorial Hypothetical 2 (Counterexample, Authorised Proxy Voting Twice, Protected by Proviso):
- Assumed Facts: W is a registered elector in Bathinda Assembly Constituency and is also the duly appointed proxy under the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961 for her husband H, a soldier serving at Siachen. W casts her own vote first (marked on her left index finger) and then applies at the same booth to cast a proxy vote on behalf of H (marked on her left middle finger).
- Analysis: W has committed no offence under Section 172 BNS. The Proviso to Section 172 BNS expressly exempts a person
"authorised to vote as proxy for an elector under any law for the time being in force in so far as he votes as a proxy for such elector"S1, s. 172.