Overview and Direct Answer
Section 170 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) defines the substantive offence of bribery at an election S1, s. 170, while the corresponding punishment (up to one year's imprisonment, or fine, or both, or fine only where bribery takes the form of "treating") is prescribed separately in Section 173 BNS S1, s. 173. Replacing Section 171B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) verbatim, Section 170 BNS criminalises both the giver (or offerer) and the receiver (or solicitor) of any gratification intended to induce or reward the exercise (or non-exercise) of any "electoral right" S1, s. 169(b); S1, s. 170; S3, s. 171B. At the same time, the Proviso to Section 170(1) BNS expressly protects "a declaration of public policy or a promise of public action": the statutory foundation on which the Supreme Court in S. Subramaniam Balaji vs. Government of Tamil Nadu, (2013) 9 SCC 659 held that election manifesto promises by political parties do not constitute criminal bribery S1, s. 170(1); S6.
Statutory Text and Sub-Section Breakdown
Section 170 BNS is structured into three sub-sections and a Proviso:
"(1) Whoever— (i) gives a gratification to any person with the object of inducing him or any other person to exercise any electoral right or of rewarding any person for having exercised any such right; or (ii) accepts either for himself or for any other person any gratification as a reward for exercising any such right or for inducing or attempting to induce any other person to exercise any such right, commits the offence of bribery: Provided that a declaration of public policy or a promise of public action shall not be an offence under this section. (2) A person who offers, or agrees to give, or offers or attempts to procure, a gratification shall be deemed to give a gratification. (3) A person who obtains or agrees to accept or attempts to obtain a gratification shall be deemed to accept a gratification, and a person who accepts a gratification as a motive for doing what he does not intend to do, or as a reward for doing what he has not done, shall be deemed to have accepted the gratification as a reward." S1, s. 170
Let us examine each statutory unit in detail:
- Sub-section (1)(i): Active Bribery (Giving / Offering Gratification):
- Actus Reus: Giving (or, via Sub-section (2), offering, agreeing to give, or offering/attempting to procure) a
"gratification"to"any person"S1, s. 170(1)(i), (2). - Meaning of
"gratification": Though not separately defined in Chapter IX,"gratification"in Indian penal law is not restricted to pecuniary or monetary payments; it extends to any valuable thing, gift, employment, loan waiver, or hospitality (such as food, drink, entertainment, or provision, which Section 173 Explanation terms"treating") calculated to satisfy a desire or serve as an inducement S1, s. 170; S1, s. 173. - Mens Rea (
"with the object of"): Either:- (a) Prospective Inducement:
"with the object of inducing him or any other person to exercise any electoral right"(including standing, not standing, withdrawing as a candidate, voting, or refraining from voting under Section 169(b) BNS); or - (b) Post-Facto Reward:
"of rewarding any person for having exercised any such right"S1, s. 169(b); S1, s. 170(1)(i).
- (a) Prospective Inducement:
- Notice that the recipient of the gratification (
"to any person") need not be the voter or candidate themselves: giving money to a community head, union leader, or family patriarch with the object of inducing other persons to vote in a particular way squarely satisfies"inducing him or any other person to exercise any electoral right"S1, s. 170(1)(i).
- Actus Reus: Giving (or, via Sub-section (2), offering, agreeing to give, or offering/attempting to procure) a
- Sub-section (1)(ii): Passive Bribery (Accepting / Soliciting Gratification):
- Unlike early unamended versions of Section 123(1) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 (prior to Act 47 of 1966), Section 170(1)(ii) BNS criminalises the voter, candidate, or middleman who accepts or solicits a bribe just as much as the giver S1, s. 170(1)(ii).
- It covers accepting gratification (either for oneself or for any other person) as a reward for exercising an electoral right, or for inducing or attempting to induce any other person to exercise such right S1, s. 170(1)(ii).
- Sub-sections (2) and (3): Deeming Clauses Expanding Completion to Inchoate Stages and Pretextual Acceptance:
- Sub-section (2): Raises an offer, an agreement to give, or an offer or attempt to procure a gratification into the completed act of
"giving"a gratification S1, s. 170(2). Thus, if a candidate's agent offers ₹2,000 per vote to a resident who indignantly refuses the money, the agent has already committed the completed offence of bribery under Section 170(1)(i) read with Section 170(2) BNS S1, s. 170(1)–(2). - Sub-section (3):
- First limb: Raises obtaining, agreeing to accept, or attempting to obtain (soliciting/demanding) a gratification into
"accepting"a gratification S1, s. 170(3). - Second limb (Pretextual / Double-Cross Acceptance):
"a person who accepts a gratification as a motive for doing what he does not intend to do, or as a reward for doing what he has not done, shall be deemed to have accepted the gratification as a reward"S1, s. 170(3). Practical significance: A voter who takes ₹1,000 from Candidate X promising to vote for X, while secretly intending all along to vote for Candidate Y (or who claims after the poll that he voted for X when he actually did not), cannot plead as a defence that he never intended to keep his corrupt bargain S1, s. 170(3)!
- First limb: Raises obtaining, agreeing to accept, or attempting to obtain (soliciting/demanding) a gratification into
- Sub-section (2): Raises an offer, an agreement to give, or an offer or attempt to procure a gratification into the completed act of
- Proviso to Sub-section (1): Public Policy and Promise of Public Action:
"Provided that a declaration of public policy or a promise of public action shall not be an offence under this section."S1, s. 170(1)- This Proviso draws the constitutional boundary between corrupt individual/group vote-buying and legitimate democratic campaigning (such as promising agricultural debt relief, tax reductions, new roads, or welfare schemes if elected to office) S1, s. 170(1); S6.
Comparison with IPC Section 171B and Section 123(1) of the RP Act, 1951
| Feature | IPC, 1860 (Section 171B) | BNS, 2023 (Section 170) | Representation of the People Act, 1951 (Section 123(1)) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Statutory Text | Sub-sections (1), (2), (3) and Proviso S3, s. 171B | Identical verbatim to IPC 171B S1, s. 170 | Defines "Bribery" as a corrupt practice for election petitions in Parliament/State Legislature elections S6. |
| Institutional Scope | Legislative, municipal, panchayat, and public authority elections S3, s. 21; S3, s. 171B | Legislative, municipal, panchayat, and public authority elections S1, s. 2(28); S1, s. 170 | Confined to Parliamentary and State Legislative elections. |
| Punishment Provision | Punished under IPC Section 171E S3, s. 171E | Punished under BNS Section 173 S1, s. 173 | Leads to setting aside of election (Section 100 RP Act) and electoral disqualification (Section 8A RP Act). |
Landmark Judicial Authority
- S. Subramaniam Balaji vs. Government of Tamil Nadu and Ors., (2013) 9 SCC 659 S6: Challenging promises of free colour televisions, mixer-grinders, laptops, and gold coins in political party election manifestos during Tamil Nadu Assembly elections, the petitioner argued that such promises amounted to electoral bribery under Section 123(1) of the RP Act, 1951 and Section 171B IPC (now Section 170 BNS) S6. The Supreme Court held that:
- Promises in a political party's election manifesto to implement welfare schemes paid out of the public exchequer after forming a government are covered by the statutory Proviso protecting a
"declaration of public policy or a promise of public action", and therefore do not constitute the offence of bribery under Section 171B IPC (now Section 170 BNS) S1, s. 170(1); S6; and - However, because unbridled freebie promises can affect the level playing field, the Court directed the Election Commission of India to frame guidelines on election manifestos under the Model Code of Conduct (note that a later three-judge reference in Ashwini Kumar Upadhyay vs. Union of India has examined the fiscal and regulatory dimensions of pre-poll promises without altering the statutory text of the Proviso to Section 170(1) BNS) S1, s. 170(1); S6.
- Promises in a political party's election manifesto to implement welfare schemes paid out of the public exchequer after forming a government are covered by the statutory Proviso protecting a
Practical Examples and Counterexamples
- Editorial Hypothetical 1 (Pretextual Acceptance by Voter: Guilty under Section 170(1)(ii) & (3) BNS):
- Assumed Facts: On the night before a Gram Panchayat election, candidate C's agent distributes ₹2,500 in cash to voter V to induce V to vote for C. V accepts the ₹2,500 and promises to vote for C, but the next morning casts his secret ballot for rival candidate D. When prosecuted, V argues that he never intended to vote for C and actually voted against C.
- Analysis: Both the agent and V are guilty of bribery under Section 170 BNS (punishable under Section 173 BNS). Under the second limb of Section 170(3) BNS, a person who accepts a gratification
"as a motive for doing what he does not intend to do"is statutorily deemed to have accepted the gratification as a reward S1, s. 170(3); S1, s. 173.
- Editorial Hypothetical 2 (Counterexample, Manifesto Promise of Subsidised Electricity, Protected by Proviso):
- Assumed Facts: At a public rally during a State Assembly election, nominated candidate M announces that if her party forms the State Government, it will enact a policy providing 200 units of free domestic electricity per month to all households.
- Analysis: M has not committed bribery under Section 170 BNS. A promise to implement a state-funded policy if elected is a
"declaration of public policy or a promise of public action"expressly protected by the Proviso to Section 170(1) BNS S1, s. 170(1); S6. By contrast, if M personally distributes private cash or prepaid electricity vouchers from her own or party funds to voters during the campaign to buy their votes, the Proviso does not apply and Section 170(1)(i) BNS is squarely attracted S1, s. 170(1).