What Section 10 does
Section 10 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 ("BNS") deals with an unusual but real situation: the court is satisfied that the accused committed one of several specified offences, but cannot say which. The section provides:
"In all cases in which judgment is given that a person is guilty of one of several offences specified in the judgment, but that it is doubtful of which of these offences he is guilty, the offender shall be punished for the offence for which the lowest punishment is provided if the same punishment is not provided for all." S1S2
In short: where guilt is certain but the label is not, the accused is sentenced on the least serious of the candidate offences.
The condition that readers most often miss
Section 10 is not the benefit of the doubt. This is the single most important thing to understand about it, and getting it wrong inverts the provision.
Section 10 presupposes a finding of guilt. Its opening words are "In all cases in which judgment is given that a person is guilty of one of several offences". The doubt it addresses is a doubt about which offence, not about whether the accused is guilty at all. Where the doubt goes to guilt itself, the answer is acquittal, and Section 10 has no application whatever.
So the section operates in a narrow space: the evidence establishes beyond reasonable doubt that the accused committed an offence, and establishes that it was one of a defined set, but does not establish which member of that set.
Three conditions, all of which must be met
Reading the words closely, the section applies only where: S1
- Judgment is given that the person is guilty of one of several offences: a finding, not a suspicion;
- those offences are specified in the judgment. The set must be identified, not left open; and
- the same punishment is not provided for all of them. If every candidate offence carries the same punishment, there is nothing for the section to resolve and the final clause excludes it.
The third condition is easy to overlook and is genuinely limiting: Section 10 is a tie-breaker, and where there is no disparity in punishment there is no tie to break.
The mapping: verbatim IPC s. 72
| BNS s. 10 | IPC s. 72 |
|---|---|
| Operative words | Identical |
| Marginal title | "Punishment of person guilty of one of several offences, judgment stating that it is doubtful of which.": the IPC read "…offences, the judgment stating…" |
This is a verbatim carry-over, the only difference being the dropped definite article in the marginal note. No condition was added, removed or relaxed. S1S4
A genuinely sharp difference between Section 9 and Section 10
Here is a distinction that is easy to verify and almost never noticed, and it is the reason this short section repays a careful read.
BNS s. 2(24) defines "offence". The general rule is that the word "means a thing made punishable by this Sanhita". But sub-clause (a) lists particular provisions in which "offence" carries a wider meaning: "a thing punishable under this Sanhita, or under any special law or local law". That list includes section 9. It does not include section 10. S1
The same asymmetry existed in the IPC. Section 40 listed s. 71 among the provisions where "offence" extended to special or local law offences, and did not list s. 72. S4 So the BNS has carried the position over faithfully rather than created it.
Editorial analysis. On the face of the text this means the two neighbouring sections operate on different universes of offences. Section 9's limit on multiple punishment applies where the overlapping offences include offences under special or local laws; Section 10's lowest-punishment rule, taking "offence" in its narrow sense, appears confined to offences made punishable by the Sanhita itself. The practical consequence would be that where a court finds an accused guilty of one of several offences but is unsure whether the offence committed was a BNS offence or one under a special law, Section 10 does not on its terms supply the answer. That is a textual inference drawn from s. 2(24) read with s. 10, and no judicial decision on it was located, so it should be treated as an argument available to be tested rather than as settled law. It is flagged because it is checkable and because it affects the scope of the section.
The procedural partner: BNSS s. 244
Section 10 presupposes a procedural mechanism that allows a court to reach a finding of guilt of one of several offences. That mechanism is s. 244 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 ("BNSS"), headed "Where it is doubtful what offence has been committed":
- s. 244(1), if a single act or series of acts is of such a nature that it is doubtful which of several offences the provable facts will constitute, the accused may be charged with having committed all or any of those offences, any number of such charges may be tried at once, or he may be charged in the alternative;
- s. 244(2), if the accused is charged with one offence and the evidence shows he committed a different offence for which he could have been charged under sub-section (1), he may be convicted of the offence shown, although not charged with it. S5
That reproduces CrPC s. 221(1) and (2), which was in the same terms. S6 So the procedural route into Section 10 is unchanged.
The relationship is worth stating plainly: BNSS s. 244 governs the charge; BNS s. 10 governs the sentence. Section 244 lets the prosecution put alternative offences before the court; Section 10 tells the court what to do about punishment if, having convicted, it cannot resolve the alternatives.
Worked examples
Hypothetical illustrations constructed for this article, not decided cases.
1. The classic alternative-charge case. A is accused of conduct that may amount to theft, or to receiving stolen property, or to criminal breach of trust, or to cheating. Under BNSS s. 244(1) A may be charged with all or any of them, or in the alternative. If the court is satisfied A committed one of them but cannot say which, and those offences carry different punishments, s. 10 requires A to be punished for the one carrying the lowest punishment. S1S5
2. Where the third condition defeats the section. B is found guilty of one of two specified offences, but both carry the identical punishment. Section 10's closing words, "if the same punishment is not provided for all", mean the section is not engaged; there is no lower punishment to select. S1
3. Where the section does not apply at all. The evidence leaves the court unsure whether C committed any offence. Section 10 is irrelevant: it begins from a judgment that the person is guilty. The correct outcome is acquittal, not a conviction for the least serious option. S1
4. The set must be specified. D is convicted on a finding that he "committed some offence in the course of the incident", without the judgment identifying which offences were in contemplation. Section 10 requires the several offences to be "specified in the judgment", so its condition is not met on those terms. S1
5. Conviction of an uncharged offence. E is charged only with one offence, and the evidence shows a different offence for which E could have been charged in the alternative under BNSS s. 244(1). By s. 244(2) E may be convicted of the offence shown even though not charged with it. If the court can identify that offence, there is no doubt for s. 10 to resolve; s. 10 arises only if the court cannot choose between them. S1S5
Common mistakes
- Treating Section 10 as the rule on benefit of the doubt. It applies only after a finding of guilt; doubt about guilt leads to acquittal. S1
- Forgetting that the offences must be specified in the judgment. An unspecified finding of "some offence" does not satisfy the section. S1
- Forgetting the final condition. If the same punishment is provided for all the candidate offences, Section 10 does not operate. S1
- Assuming "lowest punishment" means the lowest sentence actually imposed. The section selects the offence "for which the lowest punishment is provided": a comparison of the statutory punishments attached to the candidate offences, not of what the court might otherwise have given. S1
- Assuming "offence" in s. 10 has the same meaning as in s. 9. Section 2(24)(a) lists s. 9 and not s. 10, so the wider meaning including special and local law offences applies to s. 9 only. S1
- Looking in the BNS for the power to charge in the alternative. That is BNSS s. 244, the successor to CrPC s. 221. S5S6
- Expecting the BNS to have changed this provision. It is verbatim IPC s. 72. S1S4
On the "need for change"
- Documented section-specific legislative rationale: none was located for Section 10, and none would be expected for a provision reproduced without alteration.
- What the texts establish: BNS s. 10 reproduces IPC s. 72 verbatim; the procedural partner, BNSS s. 244, reproduces CrPC s. 221; and the omission of this section from the extended definition of "offence" in s. 2(24)(a) reproduces the position under IPC s. 40. S1S4S5S6
- Editorial assessment: nothing changed here, and the honest answer to "what is new in Section 10" is "the number". The value in reading it closely lies not in reform but in its three conditions, particularly the requirement of a finding of guilt, and in the quiet difference of scope between Section 9 and Section 10 created by s. 2(24)(a).
Verified judicial interpretation
No judgment on BNS s. 10 was located while preparing this article; it has been in force only since 1 July 2024. S3 Because the section reproduces IPC s. 72 verbatim, and BNSS s. 244 reproduces CrPC s. 221, authority on those provisions should continue to apply without qualification. The operative wording is unchanged in both. No case list is set out here: Section 10 is a short, rarely invoked tie-breaker whose conditions are apparent on its face, and assembling authorities for the sake of appearance would not help a reader. The one point on which authority would genuinely assist: the effect of s. 2(24)(a) omitting s. 10: is, so far as this article could establish, untested.
Related provisions in this collection
- BNS s. 9: limit of punishment where an offence is made up of several offences; note the different meaning of "offence" under s. 2(24)(a).
- BNS s. 2(24): the definition of "offence" and the list of provisions in which it bears the wider meaning.
- BNS s. 11 and s. 12: solitary confinement, the next provisions in the punishments chapter.
- BNSS s. 244: charging in the alternative where it is doubtful what offence has been committed.
Sources and disclaimer
BNS text is from the Gazette of India publication of Act 45 of 2023 S1, cross-checked against the
India Code entry for the section S2. IPC text is from the India Code version of Act 45 of 1860
S4. BNSS text is from the Gazette publication of Act 46 of 2023 S5, and CrPC text from the India
Code version of Act 2 of 1974 S6. Pinpoints and access dates are in the sources array.
This article is for education and general information. It is AI-assisted and has not been reviewed, verified or approved by a lawyer. It is not legal advice and must not be relied on for any actual case. One point above is expressly identified as an untested textual argument. Verify the current position and take advice from a qualified advocate before acting.